Documenting the truth is not so easy
AM 378 is more than just a series
of numbers and letters. It is more
than just a course, for that matter. For
those students who have taken or are
taking Professor of English Phyllis
Mannocchi's American Studies class
American Dreams: The
Documentary Film Perspective, it
has been a source of inspiration and
an eye-opening experience.
The College's only productionbased
class--which has, according
to Mannocchi, existed "in some form
since 1978" when she came to the
College--is in its last year.
At the start of the semester, the
class, which is capped at 30 and limited
to seniors, watches all sorts of documentaries
with a critical eye.
"Documentaries are often viewed as
objective, but they're not," Whitney
Lynn '09, a current student, said.
"Anything you see is edited. Her classmate,
Tarini Manchanda '09, echoed
her sentiments: "I don't really think
that there is really
any objectivity in
film...[you are]
looking at the world
through the eyes of
the film-maker."
The course
description points
to the "reality or
art, truth-telling or
f i c t ion-making,
propaganda or
objective presentation,
responsibility
of the filmmaker"
at the heart of these
discussions.
After engaging
in the work of others,
the course
moves on to the
hands-on part: making
documentaries.
Split into five
groups of six, the
students come up with a topic for a 12-
15 minute piece concerning an aspect
of life in Maine. This year, students
are researching and trying to capture
the stories of Waterville's own
Hathaway mill, the economic role of
maple sugaring, coming out as a gay
teen in Maine, the National Guard and
railfans, who are a rare and dedicated
breed of railroad enthusiasts.
Lynn's group is creating the documentary
on the National Guard.
Currently in the final stages of production,
the film focuses "mainly on
the young people...how being in the
National Guard has shifted the
course of their lives and how they
view deployment." She discussed
the stigma that has surrounded the
National Guard, especially after the
John Kerry/George W. Bush presidential
race in 2004. "People are
excited to know that we're interested
in it...it's so far removed from what
we usually do."
"It's teach-as-you-go. It gets you off
the Hill and gets you involved in the
community in [unusual and deep
ways]," she said. Maine has a rich military
history that Lynn says she is just
learning about and experiencing for the
first time in her four years in Waterville.
Manchanda, who is working with
the Railfans crew, noted the level of
difficulty and detail that goes into the
production of a documentary. "You
have to build that trust" with your
subjects, she said, in order to have an
effective interview regarding something
intensely personal.
"It's a great way to realize there's
a bigger world out there," Lynn said.
The class has left a lasting
impression on many alumni, too.
Mark Taylor '89, who took the class
during his time on the Hill, now
works as the head of production for
TNT & TBS. "I oversee budgeting,
scheduling, crew hires and daily
surprises for all of our original programming,"
he said in an e-mail.
"The class (and most importantly,
Phyllis) inspired me to follow my
dreams and work in film and television
instead of the art world."
Currently, Daniel Martin '01,
another of Mannocchi's former students,
is a producer on Dancing With
the Stars on ABC. "I learned an
incredible amount in [the class]," he
wrote in an e-mail. "From composition
and the rule of thirds to the importance
of mic'ing people you're
interviewing--a lesson I learned the
hard way in class...--I learned a lot of
about the technical aspects of production.
But even
more important,
the class,
and Professor
Ma n n o c c h i ,
helped me realize
that production
(film and
television) was
what I wanted
to spend my
life doing."
Al t h o u g h
the class
attracts students
with and
without prior
experience in
film product
i o n ,
Ma n n o c c h i
described her
students as the
"best of the
best." Yet she
expressed concern over the lack of
support for the class from both a
technological and an administrative
standpoint. As a course that requires
equipment outside of the norm, a
support network is key. "I'm tired of
fighting for this class," Mannocchi
said. "My students deserve the best."
"It's been a challenge working with
the [school's] equipment," Manchanda
said. "The class doesn't get much
attention from the administration."
Mannocchi pointed to peer institutions
who do have successful productionbased
film classes.
For Manchanda, producing documentaries--
both on her own and
through the class--has been an
incredible learning experience. "I
think it's a really effective way of
communicating...more effective
than writing a paper...for me, it's
how I learn," she said. As a liberal
arts institution, the College "should
invest in a production-based film
studies program" because film is "an
effective way to communicate
ideas," she said. "I think Colby's
missing something if people don't
know how to express themselves in
ways other than a paper."
This year's five documentaries
will be shown on May 9 in Given
Auditorium. Both students and
Professor Mannocchi are excited
to show the fruits of their labor to
the community.